P-759 Discard, or not discard, that is the question. An international survey among 117 embryologists about their decision on 50 poor-quality/day7 blastocysts cultured in time-lapse incubators.

نویسندگان

چکیده

Abstract Study question Are decisions on day7 and/or poor-quality blastocysts’ (PQB; <Gardner’s BB) use consistent among embryologists of diverse European countries and what factors influence them? Summary answer “Discard” choice prevalence was ≈40%, however inter-rater agreement just fair (Fleiss-k=0.26). Country practice, maternal age number sibling embryos each decision. What is known already Blastocyst morphokinetics morphological quality are associated with competence used to make clinical decisions, even though evaluations poorly reproducible across embryologists. Moreover, the increasing utilization PQB adoption culture beyond 144 hours-post-insemination further challenging decision-making process. Previous surveys reported limited concordance in “discard”/“use” choices made for based single 2D-pictures without cycle/patient information. However, instance whole embryo preimplantation development, reproductive history, embryos, can Different regulations mindsets may these require investigation. design, size, duration Anonymous survey Microsoft-Forms run within a large IVF-network. Each laboratory-director shared link his/her colleagues via 3 e-mails sent weekly between 22/12/2023 12/1/2023. 117 participated representing 6 Countries, 9 IVF-groups, 28 centers. Raters inspected EmbryoScope videos 50 PQBs development decided whether “use” (“transfer-fresh”/“cryopreserve”/“biopsy cryopreserve”) or “discard” them. Inter-rater measured Fleiss-k. Participants/materials, setting, methods Couples’ information (age, infertility diagnosis, previous attempts, sperm analysis, blastocysts obtained) were provided, participants asked their years experience, center location, average cycles age, colleagues, presence time-lapse-incubators. The AI-score (CHLOE-EQ, Fairtility iDAScore v1.0, Vitrolife), chromosomal diagnosis outcomes all by one embryologist not involved survey, but blinded Main results role chance Participants Italian (40%,N=47), Spanish (24%,N=28), Portuguese (5%,N=6), Czech Swedish (23%,N=27) Icelandic (3%,N=3). 2263(38.7%) 3587(61.3%) recorded. Czech, Portuguese, expressed lower (17±7%,23±14% 27±18%), intermediate (37±16%), Nordic higher (67±11%) decision rates.The responses per 37.4±24.2%(2-87). larger embryologists’ propensity PQBs/day7 (unstandardized coefficient-B:+4.4%,95%CI:+0.9 + 7.9,p=0.015). most prevalent “biopsy cryopreserve” (33.1±21.7%,2-78). Maternal coefficient-B:+2.2%,95%CI:+1.3 3.8,p<0.01) coefficient-B:-9.2%,95%CI:-15.2% -3.3%,p<0.01) influenced this rate.Overall, 0.26 (standard-error:0.003;“fair”), “moderate” (0.41,standard-error:0.037), “fair” (0.38,standard-error:0.007), (0.28,standard-error:0.006 0.009).CHLOE-EQ v1.0 decisions. No difference shown AI-scores euploid versus aneuploid (CHLOE-EQ: 0.2±0.32,0-0.9 0.2±0.29,0-0.93; v1.0: 4.2±1.6,2.2-6.7 4.3±1.5,2.1-9), while more often chose latter group (28.3±21%,9-71 41.6±24.8%,2-87). Five transferred implanted 0.001,0.416 0.003; 2.6,5.0 6.6; rates: 19%,15% 10%). Limitations, reasons caution All decide regardless regulation enforced (e.g., PGT-A forbidden, discarding viable allowed). Nonetheless, legislative, social, background might still have affected choice. included only private IVF clinics located Europe. Wider implications findings regarding PQB/day-7 inconsistent. Mostly, legislative/clinical cycles’ characteristics practice has implications, especially poor-prognosis patients. Artificial-Intelligence improve reproducibility removing intrinsic human subjectivity. it currently underpowered assess outlier Trial registration Not applicable

برای دانلود باید عضویت طلایی داشته باشید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

To P or not to P: that is the question.

In 1993 Eugene Harris, a well-known biostatistician at the NIH, wrote an editorial for Clinical Chemistry regarding the use of P values vs confidence intervals in the evaluation of scientific data (1 ). This has long been a contentious topic in the scientific world and one with which each new generation of scientists has had to grapple on the basis of arguments advanced for the use of various s...

متن کامل

Quasi p- or not quasi p-? That is the Question

The question might not be as profound as Shakespeare’s, but nevertheless, it is interesting. Because few people seem to be aware of quasi p-groups, we will begin with a bit of history and a definition; and then we will determine for each group of order less than 24 (and a few others) whether the group is a quasi p-group for some prime p or not. This paper is a prequel to [Hwd]. In [Hwd] we prov...

متن کامل

On the Performance of Early Packet Discard

In a previous paper [3], one of the authors, gave a worst-case analysis for the Early Packet Discard (EPD) technique for maintaining packet integrity during overload in ATM switches. This analysis showed that to ensure 100% goodput during overload under worst-case conditions, requires a bu er with enough storage for one maximum length packet from every active virtual circuit. This paper re nes ...

متن کامل

Discard - based Search

Interactive exploration of large distributed collections of complex, non-text data such as medical images is a challenging task because of the difficulty of creating useful indexes. To handle such tasks, we introduce a new approach to search called discard-based search. In contrast to classic search strategies that precompute indexes for all anticipated queries, discard-based search is an on-de...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

ژورنال

عنوان ژورنال: Human Reproduction

سال: 2023

ISSN: ['1460-2350', '0268-1161']

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dead093.1072